Follow this link to secure your professional
BUSINESS VALUATION
Musings on business value, sale preparation, sale negotiations, sale structure.

Archive for the ‘PrepareYourBusinessForSale’ Category

What’s my business worth?

Posted on

Are you asking about business valuation or business pricing?

Price is not always value. Sometimes it will be. They are usually different numbers. The degree of difference will change with circumstances. Sometimes the degree of difference will be small. Often it is very large.

Here’s what I mean:

  • You buy an asset for its ability to improve your life. If buying your daughter a car will improve her life, it will improve yours too. The asset has value.
  • Buying gold improves your security in troubled political times. The transaction has a price to add value to your life. That value is a last resort store of wealth.
  • The price of Bitcoin has started to move again. Bitcoin still provides the same utility as it did last month. It is still a means for universal autonomy. We can still trade it around the world with as much ease as before. As much ease as when it was changing hands at $18,000. As much ease as when it was being sold for $4,000. The value of Bitcoin has not changed wildly in the last two years. Its price has.

The value of a business is an expression of what the owner currently gets out of it, and what he will get out of it in the future. He can sit tight and wait to get out of it what he expects but at later dates. Or he can offer the business to another person at a discount to those future cash flows. The essence of discounted cash flow valuation.

The key to value based on what you will receive in future times is the risk that those cash flows will not happen. But you know the ins and outs of your business.

  • You know how to deal with its creditors.
  • You know how to twist the screws to get its debtors to pay on time.
  • You have a good understanding by now of how the inventory cycle works.
  • You have been down a road with your staff members.
  • You have a deep understanding of what competitors are up to.
  • You know what marketing efforts have worked in the past.
  • You know about the wasted money on marketing failures. You won’t do that again.

To you; the risk in the business is small. So if you were to buy your own business, you would be happy to take it at a small discount to its future cash flows. Because… certainty.

By contrast, someone looking to buy your business has a lot of uncertainty. His learning curve will be steep. And yet you want to limit the hand over period to one month. You see the problem here? An uncertain buyer sees lots of risks. Of course, his value discount is going to be higher.

Now, do you understand the disconnect between a willing buyer and a willing seller? As much as you disclose “all pertinent information”. And as willing as the parties may be. No matter how much funding is available. The risk to the buyer is much higher in the raw and even higher in her own perception. There is no getting away from it.

Your job as a business owner (who will exit someday) is to reduce risk to your buyer. Your efforts will gain you a smaller price to value discount. If that sounds obscure; it means you will sell for more.

 

 

Occam’s Razor

Posted on

An investment conference and workshop in the Winelands last week asked a question. “Where are all the deals?”
The deals, we know, are waiting to happen. The problem investors have is in the information they receive.
Investors know that deals are “there”. Their frustration is in the quality of information. Too little information. The wrong information.

Information is often so voluminous. That is as much a problem as a lack of information. It is a lack of the right information. It provides too many variables to consider at a high level.


Occam’s Razor
Simpler solutions are more likely to be correct than complex ones.
The more uncertainties and assumptions, the greater the risk of getting it wrong.


When a potential purchaser first looks at your business, she knows nothing about it. Heck, I know that many purchasers still know very little after their due diligence study! But that’s another story.

So in knowing nothing about the business, she has to make lots of assumptions. This is where your pitch deck comes in. Remove all the uncertainties. Prove your facts. Be succinct. But above all else be informative and accurate as can be.
But more than that… Give her relevant stuff.
It is all in the preparation and presentation.

People are quick to offer income statement summaries with a fast write up and an afternoon Q&A.
The very next step is too great a hurdle for unprepared businesses.

Sometimes the sellers and their brokers hand out mountains of information. Too often, it is the wrong information.

These guys have expensive specialists working for them. They should have the capacity to wade through your audit notes and adjustment accounts. But that is not where their capacity goes. Sure they will need that stuff for later due diligence. But for now, they want some high-level information.

This is what happens behind the scenes. Yours is not the only business the investor is looking at. She can only look at one business at a time. So they all go into a box. The first one to confuse her goes to the bottom of the box. And then the next one. Anything with too much work to get to the meat moves down the pile.

The business with all the information summarised and decipherable in an investment industry format… THAT one will stay open on her desk. Now you just need to make sure it is a compelling investment. But hey! You’re invested in the business, so that should not be a problem.

Recognise your Rs

Posted on

Recognise – Regroup – Refocus

  • When you started your business…
  • When you bought your business…
  • When you gravitated into your business…

Your business got to where it is today, for the most part, because you worked at it.

Nazier Ebrahim’s success is a product of planning and hard work. He knew he would sell his business one day. He needed to do so because if he didn’t, then his heirs would. He joked that he would prefer to enjoy the sale proceeds. “Rather I get myself a fast car, than this lot do”. He gestured towards an array of piercings and tattoos on his crotch fruit with their doting faces sitting at the table.

But the sale of a business is seldom as easy or as quick as selling a home. A business is a living thing. It is moody; varying between brooding depression and excitable growth.

Nazier’s business had been through ups and downs through its years. His success was the product of the tenacity with which he had directed the business.

“Direction” is what it says. The director recognises a problem. (You do it all the time.) And then by drawing on his own experience, he regroups and refocuses. Then he moves on to the next opportunity, threat, or just daily grind. Rinse and repeat.

“Rinse and repeat” is automated as standard operating procedures evolve. It takes time to create workable automation.

Successful automation makes up growing value in businesses because they become more stable. But successful automation also makes the business more profitable because stuff just happens. When the stability and profitability come together, value accelerates; driven by the complementary forces. (Which is why we avoid using simple multipliers to set prices for businesses.)

Nazier recognised that there is no point to reinventing existing automation. This is particularly the case where the system can be rented off the shelf.

So Nazier joined CSuite to make sure that his exit from his business would be smooth and cost-effective.

He recognised the problem and the solution. He has left the regrouping and the refocusing to a system which already works.

Your lousy business

Posted on

Life is not a matter of holding good cards, but of playing a poor hand well.
Robert Louis Stevenson
(also published on 26 February 2019 by Daily Maverick as its quote of the day)

Your business is as good as you have been able to make it so far. It is a thing of pride to you. It is something worth selling one day.


 


 

But when you sit across a table from a prospective purchaser, she will tell you all about the weaknesses. She will lead with passive-aggressive questions. They will leave you wondering how such a lousy business could be so precious to you.

She has to find a way of suppressing the price of the deal. That is her first step in getting the best return for her investment.

You make your surest profit in the purchase price.
about a million investment advisors on Youtube

Of course, your best deal in selling your business is in maximising your selling price. As they remind us in the many court-room dramas playing out: it is an adversarial process.

So she will tell you how desperately she wants this business. For the lowest price possible. Even if it is quite a kak business. </ironyfont> That pretty much sums up the average business buyer strategy.

Your job is to refute those claims. But if you find yourself offended and angry, things will go wrong. The best way of moving forward is to identify issues and plan responses in advance.

There are some things about your business which could improve. Every business has place for improvement. They are unlikely to improve before the deal. Your purchaser is also unlikely to improve on them post deal. When she sells the same business in a few years, she will be defending the same issues.

The difference in successes will be in preparation, and in playing the cards you have.

Our CSuite subscribers learn about the weaknesses they will face in a sale. Then they learn how to preempt the objections with facts and not emotions.

One day when you sell

Posted on

You know how you, as the owner of your business, like to be a bit of a control freak?


This post is available on audio.


Well, one day when you sell your business, you will no longer be in control of some things. As a seller of a business, you will agree that the new owner must obviously be free to take the business where she sees best. For better or for worse. You will lose control.

  • So She will take control of the overdraft – what a relief.
  • She will be losing sleep over labour relations and wage negotiations – lol.
  • She will have to juggle the cash flow at month end – she wanted to be an entrepreneur.
  • She will have access to your email account – say what?!?

Yip. It’s a thing. You cannot just delete your emails. There is stuff there which belongs to the business. It is stuff which may be – how do we put this – sensitive.

  • You know when you told your broker about what you thought of the purchaser mid-negotiation? That.
  • Or when you debated about whether to tell the purchaser about a problem with a customer. Yip.
  • That string of comments about pushing a price which is already fair. Embarrassing!

Let’s be frank. Things are said. Email exchanges are had.

So right up front. We ask all our clients to create a private email address. They should use it for all correspondence between them and brokers, advisors, and whoever else may be told about what is going on. It is just good practice.
And of course, you probably have a private email address already. So no biggie. Right?

First, you want some assurance that in the future your discussions will not be shared.

Second, you want access to the record of discussions after the sale. Because… Well please just trust me on this. A private email address costs you nothing.

Our CSuite clients know what I am talking about. This is put to bed right up front. About the same time as we put our NDA in place. It is all good practice.

There is a webinar waiting for you here. Put your feet up for an hour, and see what I am on about.

 

Tetramerginisation

Posted on

Yeah. It’s a real word. I made it up. In the world of covfefe, meandos, and expropriation, perhaps it too, will catch on.

In the merger of two entities, nothing is as simple as just adding two balance sheets together, or assuming that 1 profit plus 3 profits will equal 4 profits.

We feel that the end product of a merger of two entities should look something like this:

2018-09-10_20-40-13s

It may end up being a bit rough around the edges, but the idea is to create value, at least equal to the sum of its parts soon after the close.

But too often, the idea of making an acquisition is a lot more exciting than the eventual outcome. The result of poor planning and consideration is the destruction of value:

2018-09-10_20-45-24s

M&A history is littered with grand announcements of mergers “which will be finalised as soon as proper studies have been conducted”. A year later, the deals are called off. In the meantime, both entities have seen the destruction of value. The value of shares have been all over the place. Staff members have started looking for other jobs, worried about their prospects. Competitors are forwarding all manner of rumours around the very businesses which are trying to grow their value.

If yours is a relatively small business, then you have the advantage of being able to plan and plot carefully with the owners of the other business, well in advance of even telling your staff. If it is not going to work, it is not going to work. If you are going to struggle to make it work, at least you can be aware of the difficulties which are coming your way.

 

Your C Suite

Posted on

Remember the days when the guys who ran your business were “the directors”? That later changed to “the executives”.


This article is also available on audio


 

More recently it is the collection of chiefs. The chief executive officer, the chief financial officer, the chief operations officer. Then we all got to grips with the acronyms associated with them: CEO, CFO, COO, and CTO.

So where the directors sat on the board, the chiefs now all sit in the “C-Suite”. And these are the guys who count when you want to sell your business.

Here is why…

If your business has significant value, then you are unlikely to sell it to an individual. That means that the new owner will be an existing industry player.

On the horizontal, it will be a competitor or a complementary business which will acquire your business as “a bolt on”. On the vertical, it will be by way of selling to a supplier or a customer.

The horizontal buyer gains markets and products. The vertical gains margin for the acquirer.

When you play with your nest egg at this level, you are up against people who do this a lot more than you do. So you may have a CEO, CFO, and a COO on your side. The guys on the other side of the table will have the same TLAs (three letter acronyms), but a few others besides.

Special chief

The big suitor often has a dedicated officer to deal with you. This will be a specialist in finding and negotiating deals.


You can have your own specialist preparing you if you join our CSuiteOnline programme.


Their CFO could be given the job. Except that those people are often so engrossed in the day to day numbers. They worry about the way in which an acquisition would affect the ratios. The CFO is often one of the people who is more valuable in adjudicating the recommendation. The CEO is also trying to run a business.

In fact the entire C-Suite has to run the business. They owe that duty to the shareholders. It often appoints a non-executive director or a significant shareholder to negotiate acquisitions. But make no mistake… that person will be a specialist.

You will do this very few times in your life. Your opposite number is already prepared. He (she) is up to date on what is what in the acquisition industry. You are about to change your entire life. That is real. Right there.


Let someone who is up to date get you up to speed by joining our CSuiteOnline programme.


Their acquisition officer’s job is to get something valuable for as little as possible and on the best terms possible (for the buyer). The acquisition officer gets to look at lots of possible acquisitions. He can afford to walk away. Nobody ever got fired for not making an acquisition. (OK, there was that one time.)

Who has the stronger hand here?

When you start to push the pace in these negotiations, you weaken your position.
When you are not prepared before the discussions, you weaken your position.
When your pitch obfuscates or is unclear in standard presentation standards, you weaken your position.
When you wait until the imperative to sell is immediate, your position is very weak.

You will lose when your position is weak. By “lose” I mean you will leave a significant amount of money on the table. It won’t even be your table anymore.

Get yourself prepared. Get your business prepared. This does not mean putting your business on the market. It means getting your house in order. It means identifying weaknesses in your business and mitigating them. It means identifying and presenting the stuff that really matters to buyers of businesses.

It means you should join a programme like CSuiteOnline.

It is a scheduled, easy bits and pieces plan, in bite-size chunks sort of programme. It will add millions to the value of your business.

Data room virtual tickets

Posted on

Long, long ago in a previous century, when a company was for sale, it created a data room as a place for all the due diligence documents. Various suitors sent their accountants, bean counters, attorneys, and commercial spies to look. It was a dodgy affair.

It took the form of an actual room where interested buyers could view all the documents relevant to the target business. Nothing was allowed to leave the room. All participants signed a non-disclosure document.

Then along came fax machines. To save time, people asked for financial statements to be faxed to them. The thermal fax paper would fade, and so would the information.

A little while later the internet arrived. Then people sent all sorts of information in an electronic format, to be stored forever on the recipients’ servers. And nobody thought this was strange. There were clauses in the non-disclosure documents (if they were ever signed) which called for the destruction of all information on demand. I remember that happening once. By deal-time, everybody was just so chuffed that they either had a business or a chunk of cash. In some cases, competitors had some interesting information on the business.

More recently people started sharing dropbox links, and similar accessibilities. And then one day people woke up to the fact that trusted people shared those links with gay abandon. Control could be easily lost.

Enter the virtual data room

A virtual data room gives control of the data back to the owner of the data. He can put information into it in layers, requiring more and more permission to progress. The owner can revoke permission whenever he wants, for whoever he wants.

He can control the sort of access the visitors have. From a curtained view window to a full-screen online view, to full downloadable access, and some steps between. If he sets up his room properly, when he revokes permission, even downloaded documents will become unreadable.

21st Century stuff.

Valuation Myths: Valuation is always based on profit

Posted on
PYBFS022

A while back I suggested that business owners should spend less time worrying about their sales turnover, and consider the importance of net profit when apportioning value to their businesses. While that certainly puts us on the right track, it may also lead down a trail of misrepresentation.

The basis for the earlier assertion is that buyers of businesses are looking for a return on investment, and similar businesses with similar sales figures will be differentiated in their value by the bottom line. Nothing wrong with that assertion until we introduce some other variables.

You may recall that both businesses we previously spoke of were in different cities, manufacturing the same goods with the same turnover and similar expenses, but one had a lower cost of sales because it is closer to its principal suppliers. It had an immediate advantage with stronger cash flows, and after paying the same expenses as its counterpart, ended up with more profit. We concluded therefore that the more profitable business would be more valuable, and we are probably correct.

So for the purposes of this discussion, let’s assume that all those variables are equal; the two businesses are very close together and now have the same suppliers at the same prices, and therefore the bottom line is the same for each.

Fixed Asset Value

The variable we will introduce now is in the fixed asset value of the business. One business invested heavily in equipment twenty years ago. At the time the owner was lucky enough to be granted a loan to get up and running, and he bought his equipment very wisely. He concentrated on good German technology, perhaps spending a bit more than he could really afford at the time. But heck, it has been worth it. He has hardly had a breakdown.

Every year he takes his wife to Europe for two weeks where they spend two days justifying the trip by “visiting the factory parts division” where they purchase the dies for the next year, even if last year’s dies were only installed six months ago previously. Having placed the order (which may as well have been done online) they continue on for their annual ski holiday.

A business like this will typically have written off in their books all the machinery except the new delivery vehicle for which they paid cash. So the equipment has very little carrying value and would probably not fetch a very high price on the open market given the new computer controlled wizardry that is available today – the same electronics that makes the replacement value sky high.

On the other hand, Darrel

This business’s neighbour with the similar profit has done things differently: He was never able to get a loan because the government had introduced some social engineering into the mix at the time he got into business, and money was less easy to get hold of for him. So he relied on supplier rental finance to start with, scraping and battling along until things started to happen. With growth he invested wisely in new equipment, replacing and modernizing, and then as the whole factory hit its sales and production straps, he was able to really go to town on the latest and greatest.

He does not have the old workhorse machinery that will never break, but he does not really need to worry about that because he has a good replacement and modernising policy. The machinery is taken apart every year at the annual shut down when agent trained technicians move in, replace, lubricate and provide a new warranty for the next twelve months.

So which business is more valuable? Answers on the back of a R200 note and send to….

This situation immediately takes the “multiplar-bar-twenty” crowd out of the equation as far as providing a reliable valuation is concerned. The first owner would perhaps be grateful, but the second one would be leaving cash on the table, without a doubt.

This is a very simple example, and of course, there are other variables which come into play as well which we will deal with later. When they are all taken together, some interesting dynamics mean that valuing a business is best left to professionals who know what businesses really sell for at the current time, in the current circumstances.

Rental agreements

Posted on
PYBFS021

The sale of a business requires a rental agreement. The sooner you ensure that you have yours in your PYBFS file, the better. Why do I say this? Many business owners do not have this very important document because they have never received a copy.

Mad rush

Think back to the time you signed your first lease. There was a mad rush as you prepared to get the whole show on the road. Then there was a rush into the rental agent or landlord, some last minute reading, and queries. Then you rushed out the door to get the next step in place. You know you signed the document. Somehow the landlord always signs last. They called you later, or more likely you had to make several calls yourself. They told you the agreement had been countersigned. In the excitement of moving in, you never received a copy of the agreement. This holds true for a great many business owners I see. Whatever the circumstances, make sure you have a copy of the lease agreement, and place it in your file. Make a scanned copy and save it to your PYBFS desktop folder.

Lease reductions = higher value

While we’re on the subject of lease agreements: You should take any opportunity to lower your rental. You would be well advised to do so in the tough economic conditions we’re currently wading through. You can renegotiate at the end of a lease term. If you’re a very persuasive character, you may be able to negotiate a lower rental cost midterm.
Every Rand lower your rental, your profit will rise by the same amount. This much is obvious. The value of your business will rise by some multiple of each Rand saved. That extra value will go to your pension fund for its own growth, and so on.

So, how can you persuade your landlord to drop your rent to last year’s amount? Or can you persuade him to forego the annual increase this year? Keep in mind the effect on valuations, and you may find yourself negotiating with a bit more vigour!

Depending on your industry, you may think about negotiating a new lease in advance of selling the business. For instance, a retail store without a lease is no longer a business worth selling. Retail landlords know the value of the lease to their tenants. The landlord must commit to the new owner with a lease on the same terms and conditions as those currently enjoyed by the owner.

Most factories can be moved, albeit with some difficulty, and the move shouldn’t trouble the customers too much. Of course in boom times, suitable factory space can be difficult to find. But then again; are we in boom times?